West Michigan Real Estate Blog | Luke Bouman Team

By Luke Bouman | Luke Bouman Real Estate Team | September 2026

Gun Lake and Gull Lake are two of the larger inland lakes in the Kalamazoo and Barry County region, and buyers who want a serious lake often compare them. They differ meaningfully in size, water character, and price. Here is the comparison. As a Resort and Second-Home Property Specialist, I work both markets.

Size and Character

Gun Lake is the larger all-sports lake at roughly 2,680 acres with 17 miles of shoreline, offering a big, active recreational experience that does not feel crowded. Gull Lake is around 2,030 acres but distinguished by exceptional depth, over 100 feet, and outstanding water clarity. Gun Lake is about size and all-sports activity. Gull Lake is about pristine water and depth.

Water Quality

Gull Lake is renowned for clarity and its dual warm and cold water fishery, including lake trout, making it the choice for buyers who prioritize water quality above all. Gun Lake is a healthy, active lake, though its identity is more about recreation and size than clarity. Serious anglers and clarity-focused buyers lean Gull Lake.

Price and Access

Gull Lake commands the higher premiums for its water quality and reputation. Gun Lake offers more accessible pricing for a large all-sports lake and draws from both Grand Rapids and Kalamazoo given its position. For value on a big lake, Gun Lake. For water clarity, Gull Lake.

The Recommendation

Choose Gun Lake for a large, accessible, all-sports experience with strong value. Choose Gull Lake for clear water, depth, and a deep coldwater fishery. Verify riparian rights, dock permits, and water depth on any property. RSPS certified. The Lakeshore's most reviewed real estate team. Call (616) 344-9923.

Related: Gun Lake Real Estate | Gull Lake Real Estate | Gun Lake Buyer Guide